Darlene Gutierrez
Star rating only, no written review.
Mayfair Animal Hospital
3521 Forsyth Rd, Winter Park, FL 32792Orange CountyFlorida premises permit active since 2003(veterinary premises permit VE3165)Check with the state (opens in new tab)Matched to this clinic by address.
Real Vet Score 53 out of 100Real Vet ScoreMixedLikely 45–60 given the evidence#9 of 10 scored vets in Winter Park How ranked4.0From 248 ratings across 2 sources4.2 on Google (opens in new tab) (211 reviews)2.9 on Yelp (opens in new tab) (37 reviews)Google reviews in the last 12 months: 3.8 average from the 14 we've read, below its 4.2 on Google overallReplies to 0% of Google and Yelp reviews, 0 of 4 negative ones (of 15 read)Down 6 points since September 2026
How this score was calculated
| Ratings from | Avg | Count |
|---|---|---|
| 4.20 | 211 | |
| Yelp | 2.90 | 37 |
- Star ratings, weighted: 4.01. Member reviews count 1.5×, 3× with a checked bill.
- Last 24 months: 3.87 from 15 reviews, blended in at 25%.
- Adjusted toward the all-clinic average (4.55) with the weight of 20 reviews: 4.01.
- What 12 reviews say about care: −0.20 stars.
- Result: 3.82 stars = 53 / 100. Based on many ratings.
What pet owners say
Summary written by AIReviews for Mayfair Animal Hospital are polarized, with some owners praising the long-term trust and caring nature of the staff while others report significant issues regarding diagnostic thoroughness and communication during difficult procedures.
Often praised
- Long-standing relationships with trusted doctors
- Friendly and reassuring staff
- Attentive care for pets
Common concerns
- Inconsistent quality of medical investigations
- Poor handling of nervous or reactive dogs
- Communication issues during euthanasia
Written by AI from the reviews (members' first, then the newest), Sep 25, 2026. It can be wrong: read the reviews for the full picture.
Reviews
Write a reviewHappy Leaper
I have been bringing my fur babies to Peggy for over 20 years. I moved to Clermont 13 years ago and thought I'd find a different Vet for the convenience, but I never found anyone that I trust like I trust Peggy. View on Google (opens in new tab)
Claudane Manigat
Accordingly Labrador/rodeo pass away from Addison diseases. Dr Peggy 💀 View on Google (opens in new tab)
Brittney Artigas
Star rating only, no written review.
Olivhea Milligan
If you care about your pets, don’t bring them here. Dr Peggy does not investigate issues with animals, she draws conclusions by asking a question or two until she thinks she knows what’s wrong. I brought my dog in this morning for a bad wound on her rear left leg, explained what… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
John Wetz
Avoid these horrible people. Read the negative reviews - believe them. I made a horrible mistake bringing my pet rat here to be euthanized. So I am going to share my experience to hopefully help others not go through the same guilt. I called to see if they could euthanize my… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
Jillian Zambrana
I had my parents bring my dog in to be neutered, and he became a bit reactive out of fear. I completely understand that a 9-month-old bully breed can seem intimidating, and I respect that the clinic has the right to refuse service. Truly. However, I do feel it’s important to… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
Al Salgado
Do yourselves and your pets a favor and stay away from this place. View on Google (opens in new tab)
Kevin Faubel
The team here always is attentive and take excellent care of our pets. View on Google (opens in new tab)
Maria Moreno-Stuhler
I took Blacky today and received such a caring service! I, Betty can tell that starting with the doctor, our pets are valued and respected to the point of feeling the love! Thank you 🙏❤️ Betty and Blacky! View on Google (opens in new tab)
Joanne Bryant Knight
I went to Mayfair last week and they're even better, if that can be possible. They are always so friendly and so reassuring to me, much less my animals. The staff always pets and handles my pets with such care and understanding to what they're going through. They have a big… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
Claudane Manigat
Went to pick up after my Labrador with addison’s diseases although prognosis aren’t best… Dr on site was very positive about the outcome. Can’t wait on this new home coming. Thanks Dr Peggy! View on Google (opens in new tab)
Jonathan Long
Star rating only, no written review.
rob vogel
Always treated with kindness View on Google (opens in new tab)
Charles Rodriguez
Good vet office. Grayson rules and is very helpful. View on Google (opens in new tab)
Work at Mayfair Animal Hospital? Claim this page to reply to member reviews, or print a review card for your front desk.