Jon Holman
Star rating only, no written review.
Black Creek Veterinary Hospital
4106 Co Rd 218, Middleburg, FL 32068Clay CountyReal Vet Score 78 out of 100Real Vet ScoreGoodLikely 75–81 given the evidence#12 of 16 scored vets in Clay County How ranked4.5From 830 ratings across 2 sources4.6 on Google (opens in new tab) (784 reviews)3.5 on Yelp (opens in new tab) (46 reviews)Replies to 0% of Google and Yelp reviews, 0 of 3 negative ones (of 20 read)Down 6 points since September 2026
How this score was calculated
| Ratings from | Avg | Count |
|---|---|---|
| 4.60 | 784 | |
| Yelp | 3.50 | 46 |
- Star ratings, weighted: 4.54. Member reviews count 1.5×, 3× with a checked bill.
- Last 24 months: 4.45 from 20 reviews, blended in at 25%.
- Adjusted toward the all-clinic average (4.55) with the weight of 20 reviews: 4.52.
- What 15 reviews say about care: −0.07 stars.
- Result: 4.45 stars = 78 / 100. Based on many ratings.
What pet owners say
Summary written by AISeveral reviewers describe the clinic as a compassionate and caring facility with a professional staff that treats various types of animals, including livestock and exotic pets. While many owners praise the attentive care and fair pricing, some reports mention inconsistent communication regarding specific cases.
Often praised
- Compassionate and patient staff
- Experience with diverse species (birds, pigs, goats)
- Transparent and fair pricing
Common concerns
- Inconsistent communication regarding test results
- Difficulty reaching doctors for phone consultations
Written by AI from the reviews (members' first, then the newest), Oct 25, 2026. It can be wrong: read the reviews for the full picture.
What reviews mention
Each review is read for the topics it talks about. Bars show how many of those mentions were positive (green, from the left) or negative (red, from the right).
- Front desk and staff
- 82% positive, 18% negative, (11) mentions
- Gentle with pets
- 88% positive, 13% negative, (8) mentions
- Explaining options
- 71% positive, 29% negative, (7) mentions
- Treatment results
- 57% positive, 43% negative, (7) mentions
- Cost and billing
- 67% positive, 33% negative, (3) mentions
- Wait times and booking
- 67% positive, 0% negative, (3) mentions
From 15 reviews read by AI. Topics mentioned fewer than 3 times are not shown.
Reviews
Write a reviewrenee boatright
I took my Peking duck there that had been attacked by a large dog. Dr Sciardi was amazing! She spent so much time looking him over and answered all my questions! And their pricing is very fair!! I highly recommend this place! Your wait time my be a little long but when you are… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
Robert Wyland
First time going there and the staff was great working with my pet would recommend this place to others View on Google (opens in new tab)
crystal markley
Very experienced and caring staff i use vet services and boarding services for my pet pig here for 12 years now. View on Google (opens in new tab)
Robbie Thomson
Star rating only, no written review.
Christina Genovese (Mo)
Dr. Wyatt is just an amazing veterinarian with a such a pleasant dimenure and he really cares about his patience. Over the years, he has treated my pet pig Peppa my 3 goats, one of my chickens, and my dog Benny. I relocated to Clearwater, but for something serious, I will drive… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
Nicole Anderson
A week ago I called because my rooster developed a spot inside his mouth and I wanted him to get checked out because the antibiotic I had him on didn't help. I asked the front desk if they treated chickens. She said absolutely and they got me in the same day. I went in and the… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
AccidentDoc4u TMSD
They are very reasonable for emergency services. They are great with the animals and the Dr. I very helpful on understanding the diagnosis View on Google (opens in new tab)
Barbara Labella
Friendly staff Very gentle with my cat. He can be a pill to handle. Good vet knowledgeable good experience View on Google (opens in new tab)
Elaine Mojica
Dr Robinson and Dr Wyatt are attentive and thorough. I appreciate you so much and glad I switched from Claws and Paws where Dr Sleeper likes to withhold information assuming most people don’t want to spend extra on “unnecessary testing”. My heeler was in danger and am glad his… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
Tat Sebba Vargas
Our cat was recently treated at Black Creek on Veterinary Hospital on August 5th 2026 for blood spotting after samples and cultures were collected. He improved briefly, but the same symptoms have returned. Urinary Track infection and got only steroids. Unfortunately, he is… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
olivia day
I took my ragdoll and hospitalized for a week and the day we pick them they just found out when they carry the catvtgst there is a cyst on his lower hip I can not believe they tried to find out what's wrong with my cat and keep doing x-ray and test but never even give positive… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
Flaviu Rusz
Star rating only, no written review.
Eric Miller
Today was one of the hardest days we’ve ever had to face. Our elderly dog, Diesel, took a turn for the worse around 3:45 this Friday afternoon, September 4th. After calling his primary veterinarian of 14 years, we were told they couldn’t get him in and that we should increase… Read the full review on Google (opens in new tab)
Sammy Jam
They are genuine and truly care about animals. View on Google (opens in new tab)
Work at Black Creek Veterinary Hospital? Claim this page to reply to member reviews, or print a review card for your front desk.